I used to be such a big fan of the infamous MAC Makeup Remover Wipes. Truth be told, they are one of the best at removing stubborn red lipstick and waterproof mascara, but if you're looking for a more natural wipe, I suggest the Ology Gentle Soothing Facial Towelettes. The two things that really bug me about the MAC wipes is once you get halfway through the package, they dry out. The other is that they leave a weird feeling film on your face. The Ology wipes are the total opposite; from first to last wipe, they stay muey moist! These are also great for refreshing throughout the day.
Now, will you have to use more than one to get stubborn makeup off...yes, but I don't mind. They come 30 to a pack and are usually on sale (scored these two for $3.56ea). The one big negative for me is that I can't seem to find them anywhere in Philly at my local Walgreens, so hubby is sent on a witch hunt in NYC (he still works there) to gather up as many as he can find at Duane Reade (which is coincidentally owned by Walgreens...weird).